This Popular Theory About Why Democrats Lost Has Some Glaring Holes

There's one big question lurking behind every postmortem about why Democrats lost the 2024 presidential election.
Mr. Normand Douglas · 3 days ago · 2 minutes read


The Crisis of Trust in American Institutions

The Problem

Why do Americans have such low trust in their institutions? Some blame the "Indigo Blob," a supposed alliance of leftist elites, for pushing the Democratic Party too far left.

However, this explanation is incomplete. Influential centrists, older Democrats, and non-Ivy League groups have also made controversial decisions.

Moreover, Americans distrust a wide range of institutions, including the police, banks, and the medical system. This suggests that the issue goes beyond the influence of any single group.

The Role of the Media

The decline of the free press has contributed to this crisis of trust.

Tech monopolies have made it difficult to sustain media outlets that rely on nonpartisan fact-gathering. This has led to a reliance on opinion "takes" that reinforce existing beliefs rather than fostering curiosity or uncertainty.

Polarized media outlets reward polemical worldviews that assign blame to particular groups. This polarization-optimized discourse hinders consensus-building and distorts public perception.

Other Factors

While the media plays a role, it is not solely responsible for the dysfunction and discontent.

Other contributing factors include:

  • Money in politics
  • Sclerotic legislative system
  • Failure of regulation
  • Concentration of wealth
  • Right-wing propaganda
  • Resistance to change by older generations

The Way Forward

Rebuilding trust in institutions requires a system that can build consensus, even if it is hypocritical or ideologically bracketed.

However, the author refrains from providing specific solutions in the article.